Many Texas homeowners install security cameras and many more install Ring video doorbells. Ring doorbells allow a homeowner to see, interact with, and record anyone approaching the door for any reason. 

Most of the time, the only person who sees a homeowner’s security camera footage or Ring footage is the homeowner. Yet occasionally, police want the information recorded on those cameras. Is it a good idea to give it to them? Have you already done so without realizing it?

Here’s what you need to know. 

Never Give a Voluntary Recording Without a Warrant

As a matter of principle, you should make police cough up a warrant when they want anything from you, including security camera footage or Ring camera footage. 

You may think they are after some third-party porch pirate, but you never know. Police officers lie. They may be trying to establish a timeline that establishes your whereabouts. In addition, these devices record conversations that you might not want the police to hear. 

Don’t even give it to them through a service like Neighbors by Ring. You have no way of knowing who they’re after. 

Most people are good people who just want to help; we understand if you also have that impulse. Yet if your specific doorbell data or security camera footage data will make or break their case, they should have no problem convincing a judge that they need it. 

Police May Take the Data Anyway

Amazon admits to giving Ring footage to police departments upon “emergency” request. There wasn’t a process for judges or device owners to determine whether an emergency actually existed. 

Ring claims to distinguish between an ongoing, nonurgent investigation and a “Request for Assistance,” a request which might be extremely time-sensitive. They require police to tell them who is in immediate danger and how having the Ring data might help them respond to the emergency. 

In addition, law enforcement often subpoenas Amazon or Ring to get the data they want. 

Federal law already makes it possible to sidestep the warrant process for an emergency situation if there is an immediate danger of death or serious bodily harm to any person if law enforcement is aware of conspiratorial acts that threaten national security, or if law enforcement is aware of conspiratorial activities characteristic of organized crime. 

A Criminal Defense Lawyer May Challenge the Evidence or Use It 

If law enforcement failed to follow the law when they obtained your video evidence, we can file a Motion to Suppress. If we’re successful, law enforcement won’t be able to use the evidence against you.

In some cases, you might want to provide the data to us. We could use the data to help you establish an alibi. 

Police will continue to attempt to get as much data from technology as possible. It’s important to be vigilant about the amount of surveillance you’re under and to understand your rights when police officers wish to tap into that information.

See also:

How Law Enforcement Could Use Messenger Apps Against You in Your Houston, TX Criminal Case 

Can HPD Enter Your Home Without a Warrant? 

How Social Media Can Impact Your Houston, TX Criminal Case

A+ Rated

Houston Criminal Lawyer

icon-2
Former Prosecutors

On Your Side

experience-min
Trial Proven

State and Federal

thumbsup-min
Over 2,500 Clients

Helped in Texas

Many Texas homeowners install security cameras and many more install Ring video doorbells. Ring doorbells allow a homeowner to see, interact with, and record anyone approaching the door for any reason. 

Most of the time, the only person who sees a homeowner’s security camera footage or Ring footage is the homeowner. Yet occasionally, police want the information recorded on those cameras. Is it a good idea to give it to them? Have you already done so without realizing it?

Here’s what you need to know. 

Never Give a Voluntary Recording Without a Warrant

As a matter of principle, you should make police cough up a warrant when they want anything from you, including security camera footage or Ring camera footage. 

You may think they are after some third-party porch pirate, but you never know. Police officers lie. They may be trying to establish a timeline that establishes your whereabouts. In addition, these devices record conversations that you might not want the police to hear. 

Don’t even give it to them through a service like Neighbors by Ring. You have no way of knowing who they’re after. 

Most people are good people who just want to help; we understand if you also have that impulse. Yet if your specific doorbell data or security camera footage data will make or break their case, they should have no problem convincing a judge that they need it. 

Police May Take the Data Anyway

Amazon admits to giving Ring footage to police departments upon “emergency” request. There wasn’t a process for judges or device owners to determine whether an emergency actually existed. 

Ring claims to distinguish between an ongoing, nonurgent investigation and a “Request for Assistance,” a request which might be extremely time-sensitive. They require police to tell them who is in immediate danger and how having the Ring data might help them respond to the emergency. 

In addition, law enforcement often subpoenas Amazon or Ring to get the data they want. 

Federal law already makes it possible to sidestep the warrant process for an emergency situation if there is an immediate danger of death or serious bodily harm to any person if law enforcement is aware of conspiratorial acts that threaten national security, or if law enforcement is aware of conspiratorial activities characteristic of organized crime. 

A Criminal Defense Lawyer May Challenge the Evidence or Use It 

If law enforcement failed to follow the law when they obtained your video evidence, we can file a Motion to Suppress. If we’re successful, law enforcement won’t be able to use the evidence against you.

In some cases, you might want to provide the data to us. We could use the data to help you establish an alibi. 

Police will continue to attempt to get as much data from technology as possible. It’s important to be vigilant about the amount of surveillance you’re under and to understand your rights when police officers wish to tap into that information.

See also:

How Law Enforcement Could Use Messenger Apps Against You in Your Houston, TX Criminal Case 

Can HPD Enter Your Home Without a Warrant? 

How Social Media Can Impact Your Houston, TX Criminal Case

AWARDS & RECOGNITION
TESTIMONIALS

Rated 5/5 based on 52 customer reviews

DarkLogo
GrecoNeylandStars
Kenny McKee
Kenny McKee
17:11 11 Dec 18
They did a great job getting rid of my parking and speeding tickets. I recommended them to my friends and family. And they've also experienced the same professionalism and great quality service at an affordable price.
Brian Gomez
Brian Gomez
16:50 11 Dec 18
Dustan and his staff create the best team. They know the law, and made me feel like I was involved and understood everything that was going on. Dustan took the time to explain to me and my family what we could expect, and then led the way.
Heidi Etter
Heidi Etter
15:33 11 Dec 18
Dustan and his staff helped handle my divorce proceedings. He was incredibly knowledgeable and on top of everything I needed to do. Everything was handled in a timely and professional manner. I’m very thankful for his expertise in helping me to manage a difficult situation.
Jordan Bradshaw
Jordan Bradshaw
15:31 11 Dec 18
The staff at Greco Neyland helped a friend of mine on a case. Everyone was so nice and friendly! I definitely recommend them to anyone who needs someone knowledgeable who also really cares about their clients.
Justin Washington
Justin Washington
23:12 06 Nov 18
Dunstan and the staff at Greco Neyland are truly professional and very helpful and understanding through the process. I was facing a felony case and Dunstan got it no billed . I definitely recommend this firm if you want a lawyer that’s going to defend and fight for you.
Next Reviews Write a review
Shadow1
FREE CASE REVIEW

No Pressure. Speak To An Attorney. No Hidden Fees.

OR CALL 713.972.1100